There were more than a couple of results that warranted further inspection Saturday. The one that earned national attention was Kent State’s victory at Rutgers, which I think pretty clearly is the league’s signature win this season since it came on the road and marked the highest-ranked team beaten by a MAC school in 2012.
The one that raised eyebrows around the league was Miami knocking off previously unbeaten and nationally ranked Ohio. The Bobcats have been reeling because of injuries for weeks, but that wasn’t the eyebrow-raiser for me: How about the RedHawks claiming a big win over an East Division rival, continuing to make that a FOUR team race?
Both Northern Illinois and Toledo faced challenges on the road Saturday, but both responded the same way: Both the Huskies and the Rockets put together terrific second-half efforts to remain unbeaten in MAC play and set up a winner-take-all showdown in DeKalb on Nov. 14.
Here is a look at the league’s 13 teams, presented in the order I would rank them at this point in the season. …
1. NORTHERN
ILLINOIS
(8-1, 5-0) (LW #1): Give a little credit to Western
Michigan for giving the Huskies a challenge Saturday. But give a
LOT of credit to NIU for handling the first-half challenge, firing a few
first-half salvos of its own, then dominating the second half. This team’s
defense isn’t getting enough credit for its performance so far this season, and
the offense just keeps churning out points. Warning: Shield the eyes of young
children Saturday when Northern hosts UMass, because that violence could be
graphic.
2. TOLEDO
(8-1, 5-0) (LW #2): Give a
little credit to Buffalo for giving the Rockets a challenge Saturday. But
give a LOT of credit to UT for handling that first-half challenge, firing a few
first-half salvos of its own, then dominating the second (say, where have I
heard that before?). The Rockets have an underappreciated
runner in David Fluellen, and the
defense – despite giving up lot of yardage – always seems to create turnovers,
then convert them into points. But UT faces a couple of challenges, starting
with Ball State
at the Glass Bowl next Tuesday.
3. KENT
STATE
(7-1, 4-0) (LW #4): It was easy to slide the Golden Flashes into third
following their impressive win at Rutgers. And I must
admit, it was hard to resist the temptation to slide them even higher in this
poll. KSU will need to be focused when
facing Akron Saturday, although it
should help that it is a rivalry game. And for those of us who looked past the
contest at Miami the following
Saturday … not so fast, my friends. But are the Flashes for real? Ask Rutgers.
4. OHIO
(7-1, 3-1) (LW #3): So much for the “bigger” tests coming AFTER the Miami
game. The Bobcats failed their test in Oxford,
and things are about to get really tough for OU. I expect the Bobcats will post
a win Thursday over Eastern Michigan, but the schedule gets much tougher
quickly as Ohio finishes with Bowling Green (just six days after playing EMU),
then plays at Ball State and at Kent State to end the season.
5.
BALL
STATE
(6-3, 3-2) (LW #5): The
Cardinals posted another solid road win over Army to become bowl-eligible. Things
get harder right away for BSU, though, as their next contest comes against Toledo at the Glass Bowl next Tuesday, followed by a home game
against Ohio and the season-ender at Miami. I
was not a fan of their offense before the season began, but I have been convinced
it is solid; I would like to see more from the Cards’ defense before solidly
jumping on the bandwagon.
6. BOWLING GREEN (6-3, 4-1) (LW #6):
The Falcons have won five in a row, and the victory over Eastern
Michigan makes BG bowl-eligible. There are questions about the
quality of the Falcons’ win in that span, although I would think Miami’s
win over Ohio helped in that
regard. The Falcons need a strong effort next Wednesday against Ohio,
and Kent State
looms on the horizon. Both of those are important not only to win the MAC
East, but also to burnish the Falcons’ bowl resume.
7.
MIAMI (4-4, 3-1) (LW #8): The RedHawks got a week off to prepare for
the rivals from Ohio, and Miami certainly took advantage of that team to beat
the Bobcats and keep alive their hopes to win the East and go bowling. The
RedHawks need a strong effort at Buffalo to keep things rolling – and that won’t
be as easy as it sounds – but it’s do-able, and it’s important if Miami wants
to set up a huge contest against Kent State the following Saturday.
8.
WESTERN MICHIGAN (3-6, 1-4) (LW #7): Let’s give the Broncos credit for
a strong first-half effort against Northern Illinois, which shows what they are
capable of even without QB Alex Carder.
But the second half also showed the deficiencies of this team, especially from
a defense that should be better. The schedule eases in the coming weeks, but
rivalry games with Central Michigan and Eastern
Michigan should have this team’s attention.
9.
BUFFALO (1-7, 0-4) (LW #9): The Bulls have lost six in a row, but the
four in league play came to teams with a combined 17-1 record in the MAC
(Kent State, Ohio, Northern Illinois and Toledo). Things don’t get any easier
this week with Miami coming to town
and Western Michigan still to come (and Bowling
Green as the season-ender). It helps that Brandon Oliver has returned to action,
giving them a running game and a tool to control the clock and keep them in the
game.
10. EASTERN
MICHIGAN (1-7, 0-4) (LW #11): The defense struggled at Bowling Green
last week, and Thursday brings a road trip to Ohio – another tough contest for
a team whose last three league losses have come to teams with a combined league
record of 13-1. It looks as if this team has figured out some things
offensively, but the defense needs to buckle down as “Michigan”
games against Central and Western, followed by a season-ended against Northern
Illinois, are yet to be played.
11. CENTRAL
MICHIGAN (3-5, 1-3) (LW #12): The Chippewas won a game they needed to
win by beating Akron Saturday, but CMU needs to keep that momentum rolling
against “Michigan” opponents in Western Michigan (this week) and Eastern
Michigan (next week). Once the Chippewas cleaned up the turnovers, they were
able to score 35 points and were much more productive offensively. Believe it
or not, there are three possible wins still on the schedule – how many can CMU
claim?
12. AKRON
(1-8, 0-5) (LW #10): Last week I asked if a 2-1 record in the next
three games was too much to ask for. Answer? Perhaps, since the Zips opened
with a lopsided loss at Central Michigan. Akron
has a chance to “make” its season this Saturday with a rivalry game with Kent
State, and UMass follows, but two
wins looks a little more grim, doesn’t it?
13. MASSACHUSETTS (0-8, 0-4) (LW #13): It almost seems
unfair that this team now has to face Northern Illinois on the road after
playing at Vanderbilt last week. Surviving that contest in one piece gives the
Minutemen a chance in the following weeks, because games against Akron
and Buffalo are coming up. Can
UMass win either of those games? Yes. Will they? They will need to play better
to have a chance.
